At the beginning of this Gospel, we encounter a timeless human question: What should we do? We all face this at various points in our lives, whether regarding minor choices like what to wear, or significant matters like our relationships and health. In times of uncertainty, we often wonder whom to turn to for guidance.
Likewise, Mary faced dilemmas. She received a puzzling message of motherhood as a virgin, and Joseph struggled with whether to marry her. In her search for understanding, Mary decided to visit her cousin Elizabeth, knowing she would find the support she needed.
In a similar way, the crowds and soldiers approached John the Baptist with their own urgent question: What should we do? Their concerns were spiritual, reflecting a desire to change their lives. They were ready to confront the challenges that change might entail, fully aware that following John’s guidance would require sacrifice.
Consider Dorothy Day, who transformed her life after becoming pregnant with her common-law husband. As she contemplated baptism for her child, she felt compelled to explore her own faith. Ultimately, she chose to become Catholic, a decision that cost her dearly, including her relationship with the father of her child. Yet this choice led her to a life of extraordinary service to the poor, earning her a place in the hearts of many and a path toward canonization.
Most of us may not experience such dramatic transformations. We are more like the ordinary people who sought John’s counsel, who were advised to take simple, everyday steps—like sharing what they have with those in need.
So, the Advent question remains: What should I do to live authentically? An old Native American story offers wisdom here: inside of us are two wolves—one representing peace, love, and kindness, and the other, fear, greed, and hatred. Which wolf will win? The answer is simple: whichever one we feed.
